Tuesday, April 3

Gods, demons and historical agency

In seminar this week, we are discussing the following question: "Do animals have historical agency?" This strikes me as one of the great red herrings of environmental history (see also “commons, tragedy of the”). Agency carries so many different meanings in such different contexts that this question seems aimed at prompting knee-jerk opposition from a historiographical constituency that may not actually exist.

Let us try to unpack what this question might actually mean:

A. Do animals effect history? I think we would be hard pressed to find a contemporary historian who does not think that non-human actors can have a role in changing the course of events. Even the most anthropocentric must concede that horses had a role in the course of warfare, or that people care about national symbols like the bald eagle.

B. Do animals effect history (independent of humans)?  Many historians have never particularly considered this question, and to me it seems a moot point. In the modern world, there are effectively no animals that exist independent of anthropogenic interventions. Everywhere, animals are interdependent in a web that includes humans. In the rare contexts where this is not the case, I am not sure that we (as historians) especially care what animals do.

C. Do animals effect history (in seemingly unpredictable ways)? This is how I would interpret Brett Walker (sometimes, especially in Toxic Archipelago) and Timothy Mitchell (in "Can the Mosquito Speak?"). It is a more productive phrasing of the above question, that avoids the problematic [modernist] assumption that factors can be manipulated independent of one another. The answer is yes, clearly animals display what might be mathematically termed “chaotic” or “nonlinear” behavior. Wolves that had coexisted peacefully with humans suddenly start attacking them. Or conversely, humans that had previously coexisted peacefully with wolves suddenly start attacking them. But if this type of agency extends beyond humans to other animals, surely it also extends to phenomena like weather, currency markets and machines. If we begin talking about all of these phenomena as having “agency” it lends them equivalence that harkens back to the days of ghost in the machine and money demons coexisting with gods and men. This may carry narrative power, but I do not think it is analytically coherent.

D. Do animals effect history (through their unique symbolic power)? This seems to be where Harriet Ritvo’s main argument lies. Animals do form powerful discursive symbols. And we know that symbols have sociohistorical power. But this still fails to differentiate animals from other powerful symbols like - again - weather, currency markets and machines.

E. Are animals psychosocial/moral actors? I think this is the provocative position that Walker aims at (in Lost Wolves). The most convincing answers to this question do not come from history, however, but from the zone where evolutionary biology melds into anthropology, and psychology. Walker does make interesting use of this, combined with his personal musings. I would argue, however, that the implications here lie more in the realm of moral philosophy than in history. Walker is making a normative case - that animals should be treated as moral actors - rather than a historical case - that the moral nature of non-human animals changes the way they function historically.


Questions:
1. Does the psychosocial/moral agency of non-human animals change the way they function as historical actors? To me, this is the position that must be demonstrated before animal agency becomes an interesting question. Walker takes aim at this, and succeeds to some degree in posing humans and wolves as part of the same continuum; but I do not think he succeeds in showing that animal agency E causes animal agency C or D, merely in conflating the three.

2. Why stop at animals? We have seen Mitchel suggest (perhaps) that plasmodia and bugs have agency, and Walker argue that chemicals do as well. McNeill pêre et fils have both written about the historical power of diseases. Elsewhere, Michael Pollan (in Botany of Desire [and see also]) has suggested that plants are agents. But why stop there? Complex machines, markets and weather are chaotic systems. Even abstract phenomena like ideas and evolution behave in ways that are predictable only in retrospect. They may not have type E agency, but it is not clear that type E agency effects the broader course of history. Maybe agency is a useful way of talking about complex phenomena.

3. If we talk about weather, markets, wolves, diseases, concepts and corn as all having agency -  effecting events in seemingly unpredictable ways, being readily anthropomorphized, having symbolic power - aren't we back to a sort of polytheistic religion? And is is a problem if this takes us back to gods and demons? Contemporary theorists - Manuel de Landa and Bruno Latour, to name two - suggest that drawing clear epistemological division between natural and social processes obscures important commonalities and hybridities. This is not to say we should throw up our hands at complexity, or ascribe too much in the way of human characteristics to non-human processes - modern science and social science are not without successes. But it does suggest that we should not be so quick to look down our noses at premodern modes of thought.

24 comments:

Anonymous said...

Howdy! This article couldn't be written any better! Reading through this post reminds me of my previous roommate! He continually kept preaching about this. I'll
send this article to him. Pretty sure he'll have a very good read. Many thanks for sharing!

Look into my web site: posterous.com

Anonymous said...

I all the time used to read article in news
papers but now as I am a user of web thus from now I am using net for content, thanks to web.


My homepage :: Xerox Phaser 8560Mfp

Anonymous said...

good information, comply with these easily put in Samsung ML-1210 printer driver,
and wonderful operate.

Also visit my blog: xerox phaser 8560N

Anonymous said...

When right this problem.

My blog post: varsityadmissioninfobd.blogspot.com

Anonymous said...

This pointer truly is the best method to make tags for
individuals that have a difficult time making labels.
If you are having problem with positioning, you could adjust frames and tabs to
place it much better for on your own.

Check out my weblog: dl.free.fr

Anonymous said...

Realistic Products For bag - Some Insights
Step-By-Step Advice In shoes
Locating Simple Programs Of shoes
Considering Painless bag Secrets
Root Criteria In bag Around The UK
Insights Into Plans In shoes


http://bloodmoon.xclub.tw/viewthread.php?tid=20101&extra=
http://www.whitebirchestate.com/component/blog/comments?pid=16408
http://students.chinese.org.au/forum.php?mod=viewthread&tid=360985
http://www.blogpost.sredi-svoih.ru/blog.php?user=nm9877hjG&note=63866
http://acpma.org/forum.php?mod=viewthread&tid=30809

Anonymous said...

Where can I find free images?. Which images are usually considered free?. When is it ok to insert a picture from a website?.
[url=http://bonus-2013-ro.blogspot.com/]bet365[/url] [url=http://bonus365de.blogspot.com/]bet365[/url]
[url=http://ladbrokes-bonus-2013.blogspot.com/]ladbrokes bonus[/url] [url=http://bonus365hu.blogspot.com/]bet365 bonus[/url]

Anonymous said...

At this moment I am going away to do my breakfast, after having my breakfast coming over
again to read more news.

Here is my blog post; pilgrim jewellery wholesale

Anonymous said...

Occasionally seasons reasons some shoes drive be[url=http://niketrainersuksale.webeden.co.uk]Nike UK[/url]
little while resolution not participate in to be able to[url=http://tomscanadaoutlet.snappages.com]Toms Shoes Canada[/url]
survive such shoes dazzling[url=http://addnikecanadastore.snappages.com]Nike Shoes For Women[/url]
properly situation them within[url=http://louboutintrainersuk.blog.co.uk]Christian Louboutin Sale[/url]
true tender in position succeed to circumvent unnecessary damage of shoes[url=http://salelouisvuittonuk.webeden.co.uk]http://salelouisvuittonuk.webeden.co.uk[/url]

Although if the insole definitely is bad, tone prerequisite to perform a quiet brush and splash gently scrub. Forced to unquestionably be well-known that, shun using chemical cleaning agents cleaning, or it's mayhap that they increase the risk in return insole the beat of the priesthood off.[url=http://shoppradabagsuk.webeden.co.uk]Prada Outlet[/url]

Anonymous said...

We are a group of volunteers and opening a new scheme in our community.
Your website provided us with valuable information
to work on. You've done an impressive job and our entire community will be thankful to you.

Here is my blog :: earrings Clip On

Anonymous said...

free of cost download vista motorist.

Check out my website :: http://it.moyiza.com/

Anonymous said...

Label time of year once more! I do them in word.
The original was easy ... A few years back. Now that I have actually made deletions, it seems I can not just puttinged in another name & address in the erased (empty) place.


Whether I utilize tab, space, or ctrl tab, the pointer visits the next label position.
Yet not at the top line, to begin with a name. Why is that?
Exactly what's the answer? Exactly what am I doing wrong? I considered merely making one more label design template. That seems a great deal of operate vs a basic upgrade.
Thanx anybody ...:).

My web blog xerox phaser 8560

Anonymous said...

Sometimes the easiest method to removed installed control
series is to replicate and insert the afflicted area to note pad,
clean the text you prefer kept, then copy and paste it back.


Here is my site; xerox phaser 8560mfp ink

Anonymous said...

This text is priceless. When can I find out more?


My weblog: Private cloud

Anonymous said...

Request you to please share the operative price of Sony LED 40?
KDL-40EX520 (without 3D) and Sony LED 40? KDL-40EX720 (with 3d)

Also visit my web site: LG 42 inch LED TV

Anonymous said...

I saw plenty of website but It's my opinion this contains something special within it. "Surfing is wonderful for the soul, worries generally seems to drift apart while you scan the horizon for one more wave." by Ed Daley.

Feel free to surf to my web blog; danon jewellery israel

Anonymous said...

Was looking for tips. Will help you me in how to grow my internet business.


my web blog ... silver jewellery boxes

Anonymous said...

Thanks for any other magnificent post. Where else could anyone get that
kind of info in such an ideal means of writing? I
have a presentation next week, and I'm at the search for such info.

My web blog - UK hosting

Anonymous said...

Yes, Chad has actually offered the fundamental information.
Many thanks!

Look into my page xerox phaser 8560n - www.onlygoodporn.com -

Anonymous said...

fantastic submit, very informative. I wonder why the other experts of this sector do not notice
this. You must continue your writing. I am sure, you've a huge readers' base already!


Here is my web page; xerox 8560 review

Anonymous said...

Howdy! Do you know if they make any plugins to safeguard against hackers?
I'm kinda paranoid about losing everything I've worked hard on.
Any recommendations?

my web page - hultquist jewellery sale

Anonymous said...

Hello Design A married relationship Ring :

Feel free to surf to my website; silver Jewellery

Anonymous said...

I absolutely love that cotton reel as well as the incontrovertible
fact that it's slightly wonky causes it to be much more charming! Can I make an order? In truth I adore all of your little treasures and feel the unique way about dolls house accessories.

My web-site - danon jewellery wholesale ()

Anonymous said...

Truly Interesting. Many thanks for the Information.
I enjoy your site.

my homepage - xerox phaser 8560 solid ink